Can AI Be Trusted to Plan Lessons? Auditing the Alignment of Generative-AI Primary English Lesson Plans with China's Curriculum Core Competencies

Authors

  • Ziheng Zhang Northern Arizona Institute, Shanghai Normal University Tianhua College, Shanghai 201815, China

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.54097/wtwdfd53

Keywords:

Generative artificial intelligence, lesson planning, curriculum alignment, core competencies, primary English education, content analysis.

Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is entering primary teachers’ lesson-planning routines, yet to our knowledge no study has audited its output against the competency framework of China’s English Curriculum Standards for Compulsory Education (2022 Edition). Three chatbot models (Claude, DeepSeek, Gemini) each generated lesson plans for four official primary teaching cases from Appendix V of the standards, under a naive and a curriculum-anchored prompt, twice per condition (48 plans; 1,767 activities). Two independent automated coders of different model lineages applied an instrument derived verbatim from the standards (activity-tier kappa = 0.77), and each plan was compared with its official exemplar using Porter’s alignment index. Contrary to earlier audits, the plans were not tier-deficient: transferring-and-creating activities averaged 22.9% of each plan’s coded activities, matching the official cases (23.3%), though naive prompts fell modestly short (17.2%). Alignment gaps concentrated in cultural awareness: under naive prompts only 25% of plans operationalised Chinese-foreign cultural comparison, rising to 96% under curriculum-anchored prompts (cultural-awareness score, p < .001). Document-level competency scores otherwise saturated, and repeated generations varied noticeably. Findings support prompt-anchoring plus teacher review rather than wholesale trust or rejection.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

[1] Ministry of Education of the People’s Republic of China. Compulsory Education English Curriculum Standards (2022 Edition). Beijing: Beijing Normal University Publishing Group, 2022. (In Chinese; official English translation consulted.)

[2] Zhou A, He H. English curriculum reform in China and teachers’ preparedness to implement the latest curriculum standards. In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2025.

[3] Lo C K, Yu P L H, Xu S, Ng D T K, Jong M S Y. Exploring the application of ChatGPT in ESL/EFL education and related research issues: A systematic review of empirical studies. Smart Learning Environments, 2024, 11: 50.

[4] van den Berg G, du Plessis E. ChatGPT and generative AI: Possibilities for its contribution to lesson planning, critical thinking and openness in teacher education. Education Sciences, 2023, 13(10): 998.

[5] Trust T, Maloy R, Xu C, Pelletier K. Civic education in the age of AI: Should we trust AI-generated lesson plans? Contemporary Issues in Technology and Teacher Education, 2025, 25(3): 418–442.

[6] Dornburg A, Davin K J. ChatGPT in foreign language lesson plan creation: Trends, variability, and historical biases. ReCALL, 2025, 37(3): 332–347.

[7] Lammert C, DeJulio S, Grote-Garcia S, Fraga L M. Better than nothing? An analysis of AI-generated lesson plans using the Universal Design for Learning and transition frameworks. The Clearing House, 2024, 97(5): 168–175.

[8] Baytak A. The content analysis of the lesson plans created by ChatGPT and Google Gemini. Research in Social Sciences and Technology, 2024, 9(1): 329–350.

[9] Powell W, Courchesne S. Opportunities and risks involved in using ChatGPT to create first grade science lesson plans. PLoS ONE, 2024, 19(6): e0305337.

[10] Cooper P K. Music teachers’ labeling accuracy and quality ratings of lesson plans by artificial intelligence (AI) and humans. International Journal of Music Education, 2024, 44(1): 23–36.

[11] Karaman M R, Goksu I. Are lesson plans created by ChatGPT more effective? An experimental study. International Journal of Technology in Education, 2024, 7(1): 107–127.

[12] Tekin S, Atar C. “Hey, ChatGPT! Prepare me a lesson plan...”: How EFL teacher candidates enact AI-generated lesson plans. Journal of Learning and Teaching in Digital Age, 2026, 11(3): 220–236.

[13] Nyaaba M, Zhai X. Developing a theory-grounded AI tool for the generation of culturally responsive lesson plans. Computers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2025, 9: 100474.

[14] Lan X, Yao W. Quality assessment and feasibility analysis of AIGC-assisted lesson plan development. Journal of Guangxi Vocational and Technical College, 2025, 18(6): 7–13. (In Chinese)

[15] Porter A C. Measuring the content of instruction: Uses in research and practice. Educational Researcher, 2002, 31(7): 3–14.

[16] Webb N L. Issues related to judging the alignment of curriculum standards and assessments. Applied Measurement in Education, 2007, 20(1): 7–25.

[17] Li S, Deocampo M F. An analysis of senior high school English textbooks’ core competencies using China’s English curriculum standard framework. Arab World English Journal, 2022, 13(4): 162–182.

[18] Näsström G, Henriksson W. Alignment of standards and assessment: A theoretical and empirical study of methods for alignment. Electronic Journal of Research in Educational Psychology, 2008, 6(3), No. 16: 667–690.

[19] Feinstein A R, Cicchetti D V. High agreement but low kappa: I. The problems of two paradoxes. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1990, 43(6): 543–549.

Downloads

Published

16-11-2026

How to Cite

Zhang, Z. (2026). Can AI Be Trusted to Plan Lessons? Auditing the Alignment of Generative-AI Primary English Lesson Plans with China’s Curriculum Core Competencies. Journal of Education, Humanities and Social Sciences, 65, 74-81. https://doi.org/10.54097/wtwdfd53